TL;DR
Are schools dropping Google Search because of AI?
New York, Los Angeles and Chicago schools may drop Google Search after Google said schools can't turn off its AI features without losing Search. Your child's school search tools could change next year. Nothing yet, but ask your school what its Google account allows students to use.
Why are schools upset with Google?
On Wednesday, November 18, 2026, The New York Times reported that Google told schools a hard choice was coming. Starting next year, a school that turns off Google's Gemini-powered features, the AI tools built into Google's products, will not be able to keep Search on its own. The Verge picked up the report the same evening.
Chris Phillips, Google's vice president of education, told the Times that "Search and AI are deeply integrated," and that schools that turn off Google's AI features "will not have access to Search."
For a school, that matters a lot. Google Search sits behind homework, research projects and lesson planning. Many districts already run on Google Classroom and Chromebooks, so Search is usually the default tool students reach for.
Which school districts might stop using Google Search?
The three named so far are among the largest public school systems in the country: New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago.
- New York City: schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels told the Times, "If Google doesn't reconsider their position, we will explore other search options."
- Chicago: the district has reportedly told Google that if it can't provide a version of Search without AI, "the district will look to other search solutions."
- Los Angeles: the reporting says LA is considering alternatives too, with no public statement quoted yet.
No district has switched yet. These are warnings, aimed at getting Google to change course.
The Verge also reports that several elected officials, including New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders, called Google's approach "extortion." Mamdani had recently announced a policy barring younger students from using AI in the classroom, The Verge said.
What did Google say?
In a statement to The Verge, Google spokesperson Laura Breen said the company hears "parents and teachers' concerns about students using AI to shortcut learning." She pointed to two changes:
- Guided Learning in Search. Google is starting a pilot this month that walks students "step-by-step through a range of complex problems, instead of just giving quick answers."
- New default controls next year. "Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be off by default until schools decide which services to enable."
That second change helps a little: schools would start from a blank slate and pick services on purpose. It doesn't answer the main complaint, though. Nothing in the statement says a school can keep plain Search with the AI turned off.
Google hasn't published a blog post on the school controls, so the statement is the only official word for now.
Why do teachers worry about AI in Search?
Educators worry that AI answers can let students skip the thinking part of homework. The Verge notes that some studies have found students who use AI generally do worse on exams, and that there are concerns about young kids forming relationships with chatbots.
AI features in Search can mean an AI-written summary at the top of results, so a student may get an answer before they ever open a source. For a teacher trying to teach research skills, that changes the assignment.
Leaving Google is hard, though. As The Verge points out, Google is deeply embedded in US classrooms, and going fully Google-free "might prove difficult." A district could change its default search engine and still run Classroom and Chromebooks, but that takes setup work across thousands of devices.
AI is also getting deeper inside regular Search: Google now runs its Gemini 4 Hydrogen model in Search for everyone, so the AI layer schools are pushing back on keeps growing.
X reactions
In addition to letting schools opt out of AI feature from search, Google should also let any individual user opt out of it too.
— Yao Lin (@dikaioslin) November 18, 2026
Our take
Tying Search to AI for schools is a bad call, and we think Google will blink. The districts aren't asking for anything exotic. They want the search box they've used for twenty years without an AI summary sitting on top of every homework question.
"Off by default" is a real step, but it skips the actual request. Schools need a plain Search option they can turn on by itself, and the biggest districts in the country have the leverage to get one. Smaller districts should watch closely, because whatever New York, LA and Chicago win will likely become the rule for everyone.
— Artificially Nerdy
What to do now
- Ask your child's school which Google services are turned on for student accounts, and whether AI features in Search are among them.
- Watch for a district notice early next year, when Google's new "off by default" controls are due.
- Talk with your kids about AI summaries in search results: they're a starting point, and the real sources are the links below them.
- Teachers: keep an eye out for the Guided Learning pilot in Search this month, and try it before students do.
FAQ
Can my child's school turn off Gemini but keep Google Search?
Not under the plan Google described for next year. Google told the Times that schools turning off its AI features "will not have access to Search."
When does the change start?
Google said "next year" without giving a date.
What is Guided Learning in Google Search?
It's a mode Google is piloting for students this month. Google says it walks students step-by-step through hard problems instead of just giving quick answers.
Does this affect my personal Google account?
No. The reporting covers school-managed Google accounts only.
Sources
- The Verge: The nation's largest school districts consider ditching Google Search — November 18, 2026, 6:18pm ET. Google's statement, Samuels and Chicago quotes, Mamdani and Sanders reaction.
- The New York Times (original report, paywalled; cited via The Verge).
- Yao Lin on X — November 18, 2026, about 9:58pm ET.




